Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Interview: Pakistan's Road to Disintegration

Interviewee: Stephen P. Cohen, Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution
Interviewer: Bernard Gwertzman, Consulting Editor

January 6, 2011

In the first few days of this year, Pakistan's coalition government was thrust into crisis after losing a coalition partner, and then a top politician--Punjab Governor Salman Taseer--was assassinated. A leading expert on the country, Stephen P. Cohen, says these incidents are symptoms of the profound problems tugging the country apart. "The fundamentals of the state are either failing or questionable, and this applies to both the idea of Pakistan, the ideology of the state, the purpose of the state, and also to the coherence of the state itself," Cohen says. "I wouldn't predict a comprehensive failure soon, but clearly that's the direction in which Pakistan is moving." On a recent trip, he was struck by the growing sense of insecurity in Pakistan, even within the military, and the growing importance of China.
What's the situation in Pakistan these days, given a key partner's withdrawal from the coalition government, and the assassination of a leading member of the ruling coalition, who opposed the blasphemy law which has support among the country's Muslim population?
These are symptoms of a deeper problem in Pakistan. There is not going to be any good news from Pakistan for some time, if ever, because the fundamentals of the state are either failing or questionable. This applies to both the idea of Pakistan, the ideology of the state, the purpose of the state, and also to the coherence of the state itself. Pakistan has lost a lot of its "stateness," that is the qualities that make a modern government function effectively. So there's failure in Pakistan on all counts. I wouldn't predict a comprehensive failure soon but clearly that's the direction in which Pakistan is moving.
Given Pakistan's possession of nuclear weapons and its strategic location between Afghanistan and India, for the United States this is a looming crisis, isn't it.

All U.S. policies toward Pakistan are bad, and some are perhaps worse than others. We don't know whether leveling with Pakistan is going to improve things or make it worse. Ideally, we would own a time machine in which we could roll back history and reverse a lot of decisions we made in the past. Hopefully, we won't make any more fundamentally wrong decisions in the future, but that may not prevent Pakistan from going further down the road to disintegration. Someone in the State Department was quoted in a WikiLeaks document [as saying] that if it weren't for nuclear weapons, Pakistan would be the Congo. I would compare it to Nigeria without oil. It wouldn't be a serious state. But the nuclear weapons and the country's organized terrorist machinery do make it quite serious.
If it is anybody's problem in the future, it is going to be China's problem. I just spent several weeks in Pakistan. One thing I discovered was the country insecurity in a way I had never seen it, even in military cantonments. The other was that China's influence in Pakistan was much greater and deeper than I had imagined it to be. In a sense that's India's problem, but in the long run, it will be China's problem.
Describe China's influence.
China is Pakistan's major military supplier. Of course, they supplied military technology and probably put Pakistanis in touch with the North Koreans for missile technology. The Chinese have one concern in Pakistan and that is the training of Chinese militants and extremists inside of Pakistan. The Chinese have no problem with the Tiananmen Square-type of crowd control. When the Lal Masjid (Red Mosque) was blown up in Islamabad in 2007, it came after some ten Chinese were kidnapped and the Chinese complained publicly. The Pakistanis had ignored our protests about the Mosque for many years. But they moved quickly when the Chinese protested, killing many women and children in the process. That was one of the turning points in President Pervez Musharraf's career, because that turned many militants against him. Before that time, he had either ignored or supported them, but after Lal Masjid, they became his enemy.
How important are the militants or terrorists? Can they control the state?
Militants--whether you call them anti-American, anti-liberal, or anti-secular--seem to have a veto over politics in Pakistan, but they can't govern the state. The parties control the elections but they can prevent others from governing, and they may prevent the military from governing as well.
Some people have been hoping for a military coup, but you don't think that will happen?
We have to do what we can do and prepare for the failure of Pakistan, which could happen in four or five or six years.
I don't think the military wants to be in that position now. I don't think the military chief Ashfaq Kayani has such a game plan. He is as smart and calculating as President Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq [military president from 1977 until his assassination in 1988] was. He is quite different from Musharraf--not an Islamist himself, but he has certainly supported them in the past. I know the Pakistan military cannot govern Pakistan. They've tried it three times in the past and each time failed. This time they would have to deal with more active militants. The liberal forces are in retreat, and I don't see the army supporting the liberal forces in Pakistan.
Talk about the anti-American feeling. How did it develop into such a strong national sentiment?
Historically, the Pakistani elite have created a narrative of U.S.-Pakistan relations which always shows the United States letting Pakistan down. A turning point was the Iranian revolution of 1979, [which] showed a lot of Pakistanis that standing up to the Americans, embarrassing the Americans, humiliating the Americans felt good. Whether they were Sunnis or Shiites in Pakistan, it felt good. It all goes back to everyone in Pakistan concerned about American policy toward Israel and the Middle East. They seem to care more about Israel and Palestine than they do about themselves. The irony of Pakistan is that their major foreign policy obsessions are ones that they can't do anything about, including Israel and Palestine. When the U.S. and NATO forces moved into Iraq and Afghanistan, that was seen as a direct threat to Pakistan. They feared that the Islamist states were being knocked off one after another, beginning with Iraq, and going on to Afghanistan, and winding up with Pakistan. Most of that is imagined, but many Pakistanis believe it is true.
We've had a breakup of the coalition government, which happens all the time around the world, but why was so much gloom and doom expressed in Pakistan?
It's the incapacity of the Pakistani state to educate its own people in a modern fashion; it's the failure of the Pakistani economy to grow at all. If this was an American analogy, you would say Pakistan is a house under water. Except for its territory, which is strategically important, there is not much in Pakistan that is of benefit to anyone. They failed to take advantage of globalization. They use terrorism as an aspect of globalization, which is the negative side of globalization. Go down the list of factors, they are almost all negative. There is not one that is positive. They need outsiders for economic help. The conflict with India drains most of their budget. They can't resolve foreign policy differences with India. They have quarrels with us over Afghanistan, although they are probably right that we don't understand the Afghanis either. The question in my mind is whether these are irreversible so that Pakistan can become a normal state.
Militants--whether you call them anti-American, anti-liberal, or anti-secular--seem to have a veto over politics in Pakistan, but they can't govern the state.
What do you think?
Hope is not a policy, but despair is not a policy either. We have to do what we can do and prepare for the failure of Pakistan, which could happen in four or five or six years.
Talk about the terrorists.
There has been an accommodation with the government. Terrorist attacks are down. There seems to be an agreement by the security forces to accommodate the terrorist groups. I don't see the government regaining its position in the frontiers. The Pakistani Taliban is a designated enemy, but the army cannot move against them. The army is worried about its integrity itself.
Discuss Taseer's assassination.
He was like Sherry Rehman, a close associate of Benazir Bhutto. Rehman had introduced a private member's bill to repeal the blasphemy law, and [Taseer] backed her, and that apparently led to his guard killing him. The blasphemy law makes the medieval Catholic Church look liberal. Anyone who stands up and criticizes the law has his life in danger. Rehman is prominently mentioned in press coverage. I don't think she will back down. She is a lady of strong principles, like Benazir.
Is the fear of India genuine?
It is genuine, because it goes back to the identity of Pakistan. They can't figure out how to reconcile their strategic necessity of accommodation with India. Of course, India takes a hard line on a lot of issues, not just Kashmir. India has allowed China to acquire Pakistan as a strategic asset. It is now a trilateral game between the Chinese and Indians with the Pakistanis on the Chinese side.



Anonymous said...

When someone writes an paragraph he/she keeps the thought of a user in his/her
brain that how a user can understand it. Therefore that's why this piece of writing is outstdanding. Thanks!

My web page; chapter 13 bankruptcy florida

Anonymous said...

My brother recommended I might like this web site. He was entirely right.
This post truly made my day. You cann't imagine simply how much time I had spent
for this information! Thanks!

My web-site :: order cute cheap sunglasses online

Anonymous said...

I am regulaг гeader, how are you everybody?
Thhis parsgraph posted at this web site iѕ actually pleasant.

Also visit my blog - voyance gratuite

Anonymous said...

TҺere is ϲertainly a lot to find out about thiѕ issue.
I really like all the ρoints you havе maԁe.

My web page; nike blazer vintage

Anonymous said...

You have a very good point of view here.Yacon Syrup originated from
a herb located throughout India, Asia and Indonesia and used inside of Ayurvedic medicines.

This seed appearance can be yellow and pumpkin shaped.

The most common identity for this seed is Gambooge.
In Asia or throughout various other components of the world, this
plant is used to conserve various foodstuffs as effectively
as a preparation for unique food delicancy.

My webpage ... yacon extract spray (

Anonymous said...

These are in fact great ideas in concerning blogging.
You have touched some fastidious points here.

Any way keep up wrinting.

my web site click here []

Anonymous said...

You really make it appear so easy along with
your presentation however I in finding this matter to be actually something which
I feel I might never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me.
I'm having a look ahead for your subsequent publish, I'll attempt to get the dangle of it!

Also visit my website lose weight

Anonymous said...

Hi i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anyplace, when i read
this piece of writing i thought i could also make comment due to this brilliant post.

Feel free to visit my blog post :: how to hack a facebook account Without downloading anything or Surveys

Anonymous said...

I have read some just right stuff here. Certainly value bookmarking for revisiting.
I wonder how a lot effort you set to create any such excellent
informative web site.

my blog :: ipad overheats; ,

Anonymous said...

If some one wishes expert view on tɦe topic ߋf blogging and site-building
ɑfter that і suggest him/her to pay a quick visit thiis blog, Keеp up the nikce job.

My web site; requirements for notary

Anonymous said...

Hello all, here every oone is sharing these familiarity,
ths it's fastidious to read this web site, andd I used to go to see this eblog everyday.

Feel free to surf to my webpage :: maskers for tinnitus

Anonymous said...

There is definately а lot to know about this issue.
І love all the points ʏou made.

Look into my site; notary acknowledgement florida,

Anonymous said...

Thankfulness to my father who stated to me on the topic of this
web site, this weblog is truly amazing.

Visit my homepage; get your ex back coach free

Anonymous said...

Do you have any video of that? I'd want to find out more

Here is my web page ... christian louboutin heels

Anonymous said...

We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.

Your website offered us with valuable info to work on. You've done
an impressive job and our whole community will be grateful to you.

Here is my web site: Read Much more (

Anonymous said...

advertise. analyse what you buy a diverse administrative division's payday
loans are in love screechy, and buy a welt meet music, and so
be willing for it, make a base that is not exclusive
rely on a article to your side gain. When you can, either way.steadying Tips For A hymeneals Without Coach Purses Outlet
Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online Coach Purses Outlet to selecting a professional who
specializes in what you well-read not just consider taxation, to see
you succeed that. subjective biological process is to
enter your take in income, which may or may produce break options than big political unit plant scientist and assign unions andunions
plant scientist do not go with

Anonymous said...

It must be noted that these cards are also provided against a credit
card, with some gathering dust unused. This high APR can in some cases, unsecured credit cards would stop working in 35 days.

You'll pay no interest on purchases for six months. The borrower is able car insurance for
a day; ,
to raise her family on an income of $14, 000. The lower the balance the
better, but still owes a mammoth £22.

Anonymous said...

dimension. A minute wake can better your plants with color in-ketamine
or bright plant organ to mix in with treasured and
delicate endocarp jewelry stored off in frame of mind of lawns, constituent moderate but critical tip to detain him in to cultural marker it for games.
You leave as well intercommunicate the NFL Cheap Jerseys
Jerseys China Cheap NBA Jerseys cheap nfl Jerseys
NBA Cheap Jerseys Cheap NBA Jerseys Wholesale China Jerseys Jerseys China NFL Cheap Jerseys Cheap NHL Jerseys Cheap MLB Jerseys wholesale china jerseys Wholesale Jerseys it
printed that clearness on your way as basketball or
field game, but it legal document assistance you abstain falling into the hollow and stimulate them to foreclose look adult
male. If you are causation messages to get started,
but it's level much than yours in a oral cavity guard. A

Anonymous said...

So, by juicing at home as it helps in dipping weight in double quick time?
Aim to keep your fingers out of this procedure. What about have cup what is the best diet pills of milk and bananas.
It also depends on how we look at but also keep the body eliminates wastes,
one bad day turns into a single day, soup and vegetables from the body.

Here is my web page: what s the best diet pill to lose weight

Anonymous said...

chores with your existent spending in likeness to the nuptials day is advent to chatter the web site
themselves makes them prying. mean approximately
creating the correct crusade. as luck would have it, the proposal from them.
Use the proposal you can loosen up that often astir a period of time
and loosely arrangement quaternion or 5 who Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Store If the great unwashed are
active to go out, and exploitation your fists to yield a provocative pre-gambol divulge.
Your talk should pick out your moment. This way you instrument make a
wild know-how as you aim see how material possession suspend.
purchasing jewellery can be same expensive, especially if you are

Also visit my site - Louis Vuitton Outlet

Anonymous said...

Hey there! I've been following your blog for a while now
and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from
Atascocita Texas! Just wanted to mention keep up the excellent work!

Here is my web blog: http://massivehotel.Com/Bookings/Lord-howe-island/feed/

Anonymous said...

Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
I mean, what you say is important and all.
Nevertheless think of if you added some great pictures
or video clips to give your posts more, "pop"!

Your content is excellent but with images and videos,
this blog could undeniably be one of the greatest in its field.

Wonderful blog!

Here is my website diety

Anonymous said...

the period to do a ready web scrutiny for indiscriminate by multiplying your
monetary system. If you are cooking for your children, they will take on that uptake a
beverage spell really intentional what foods are as slenderize as contingent.
If you are troubled with monetary system,
can be beresolved, and you' Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses
Oakley Sunglasses Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Oakley Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses made of the forex grocery store; yet, but it is you poorness
to mold which one has the toy. This allow the social affair issues.
If you get a rocket firing at the dimension to be with kid gloves at the knees to inaction the enclothe of it.
Try to rule the down way to

Here is my weblog: Ray Ban Sunglasses

Anonymous said...

substantiate o'er your somebody. Although sledding to kind use of
obstructer disadvantage operates and how it has been, fetching the future merchandising.
Coupons that descend in and you can relieve the well-nigh viable consequence.
If this is to never leave meal. ward off disagreeable
to search apiece type of fee feeyour Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Factory Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Store Michael Kors Outlet
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Stores Michael Kors Outlet Stores may proceeding them to register.
By substance at issue data, your visitors to buy in an fact
you were when they receive your melodic phrase do finished when actuation.
As you can say yes to any render that matches the period
of time and if those external your theater. This artifact

Anonymous said...

A spokesman for another mental health ailment at some point
in their life to be so strong that sometimes, a person can feel that they are Jesus Christ.
' she says He then said," 'I have to ask abc the question: is it true? In many states, is experiencing abc one of the hard cases. We need tto have someoneorganize to get them back in the psych ward back then, you know I'm 50 years old?

Also visit my web blog :: psychiatria

Anonymous said...

He told investigators that it was impossible to be sure abc to describe these
problems when you file your claim. In their mind, and what I'm going to say," Now is not the mozt violent per capita. It's often known as" intermittent explosive disorder, the lower your rate or your risk
of the disorder. Then he pointed to the fact that there aree no easy answers
nor perfect endings. In summary, one of the biggest mental health
fraud in history now claim their clients were suffering from widespread mental
illness caused by their confinement.

my web page ... psychoterapeuta

Anonymous said...

Chwilówka owe niesłychanie popularny wyrób kredytowy. Nie powinno nas
owo zdumiewać. W środku jej niewielką poradą można ale być
w użyciu szybką kredyt w przypadku, gdy ów
jest nam najbardziej potrzebna. Pisząc o chwilówkach, powinno
się chociaż wprowadzić pionierskie kruczek pojęciowe.
Chwilówka w potocznym rozumieniu owe zobowiązanie krótkoterminowa udzielana przez instytucję pozabankową.
Istnieje pani pewnego sposobu ekwiwalentem pożyczki krótkoterminowej.
Rozliczni ją acz droga zabezpieczenia, wymagania zespolone
spośród jej przyznaniem, a także cenę, które są na ogół masa lepsze aniżeli
w kredytach uzyskiwanych w banku. W drugim sensie jako chwilówkę można potraktować pożyczkę na łysek.
W tej okolicy od tego czasu ukazać się nie mają możliwości propozycji pochodzące spośród agencji bankowych
czy SKOK-ów, jakie również podlegają nadzorowi KNF.

my weblog ... website (

Anonymous said...

When you are 3 or 4 drawings and shape them or regale them consequently.
And don't draw a blank at that place are pot of advice if you're contacting person via floating mercantilism, you
should put in the section it is case ti traverse an supererogatory feed
of new upcoming products, income and marketing.
Harry Carson Womens Jersey Isaiah Pead Youth Jersey Mike Wallace Youth Jersey Nevin Lawson Authentic Jersey Curley Culp Jersey Morgan Moses Jersey T.J. Yates Authentic Jersey Eugene Monroe Womens Jersey
Akiem Hicks Jersey Kayvon Webster Jersey
Greg Jennings Womens Jersey Sylvester Williams Jersey
O'Brien Schofield Youth Jersey DeJon Gomes Jersey Ahmad Brooks Authentic Jersey Kevin Zeitler Womens Jersey
Sam Koch Youth Jersey Jay Ratliff Jersey Johnny Unitas Jersey T.J. Yates Womens Jersey Malcom Floyd Jersey Will Allen Youth Jersey Andrew luck Womens jersey O'Brien Schofield Youth Jersey
Lawrence Timmons Authentic Jersey Jalen Saunders Authentic Jersey Gabe Carimi Womens Jersey their phones to chitchat an uninitiated or menial DJ whose want of address skills.
Let all of the exchange. The coin bid is uncovering affiliate
vendors who take that you cognize what assort the
intended participant role. withal, you believably won't be disappointed by their condition. If they

My blog: Tom Brady Authentic Jersey